Black v fife coal co ltd 1912 a.c. 149
WebWe now come to a case decided by the House of Lords in Butler (or Black) v. Fife Coal Co. Ltd. (1912) 1912 A.C. 149. In this case the husband of the plaintiff was killed by an outbreak of poisonous gas while working in the employment of the defendants, a limited company, in a coal mine of which they were owners. WebFor instance, in Black v. Fife Coal Co. Ltd. 1912 AC 149 at p. 165 Lord Kinnear observed : "If the duty be established, I do not think there is any serious question as to the civil …
Black v fife coal co ltd 1912 a.c. 149
Did you know?
Web(first recognised in Black v Fife Coal Co Ltd [1912] AC 149) -Developed to mean that employer must instruct staff properly: not enough to supply safe equipment if not … WebJul 6, 2016 · There are many examples of this exception in practice, dating back more than 100 years, for example (in England) to Groves v Lord Wimborne [1898] 2 QB 402, relating to the Factory and Workshop Act 1878, and in Scotland in Black v Fife Coal Co Ltd, 1912 SC (HL) 33; [1912] AC 149, concerning the Coal Mines Regulation Act 1887.
WebThe often-quoted remarks of Lord Simonds in L.N.E.R. v. Berriman 3 instance the strict approach; those of Lord Shaw of Dunfermline in Black v. The Fife Coal Co., Ltd.4 and … WebAs Lord Kinnear put it in Butler (or Black) v.Fife Coal Co. Ltd. [1912] A.C. 149, 165, in the case of sucha statute... Richardson & Ors v. Rivers. 17. Court: Scottish Sheriff Court. Date: May 7, 2004. Cited By: 0...31.4. (4) The inherent jurisdiction did not provide a justification for asking for a second note. Reference was made to Esso ...
WebMar 9, 2024 · legislation. As Lord Kinnear put it in Butler (or Black) v. Fife Coal Co. Ltd. [1912] A.C. 149, 165, in the case of such a statute: ‘There is no reasonable ground for maintaining that a proceeding by way of penalty is the only remedy allowed by the statute . . . We are to consider the scope and purpose of the statute and in particular for Webrelating to the Factory and Workshop Act 1878, and in Scotland in Black v Fife Coal Co Ltd, 1912 SC (HL) 33; [1912] AC 149, concerning the Coal Mines Regulation Act 1887. In the latter case, Lord Kinnear said (pp 45 and 165-166): “We are to consider the scope and purpose of the statute, and in particular for whose benefit it is intended. Now ...
WebThis appeal, which is brought from an Order of the Court of Appeal setting aside a judgment given by Mr. Justice Oliver in favour of the Appellant, can be determined upon a preliminary point, and your Lordships need not be troubled by a detailed narration of the facts which occupied the time of the learned trial Judge for many days. 2
WebBest Heating & Air Conditioning/HVAC in Ashburn, VA 20147 - Reddick & Sons, Air One Tech, Clover Services, Ashburn HVAC, John Nugent & Sons, RES Heating & AC, Relax … che new jerseyWebThis finding in law which your Lordships are asked to review is based upon a series of specific findings in fact, which by the statute regulating appeals of this description this … chen exo filhoWebApr 25, 2024 · Butler (or Black) v Fife Coal Co, Ltd: HL 19 Dec 1911. The court considered whether a civil remedy existed for breach of statutory duty. Lord Kinnear said: ‘If the duty … flights dc taipeiWebJun 5, 2001 · Per Lord Kinnear in Black v Fife Coal Co Ltd [1912] AC 149, cited with approval by Lord Simonds in Cutler at 407 5. [2001] 2 Lloyd's Rep. 443 6. Per Lord Kay in George Ziemniak v ETPM Deep Sea Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 636 at paragraphs 7. Lord Kay in Ziemniak at paragraphs 42-47 Th..... +44 (0) 20 7284 8080. Legislation; flights dc taiwanWebIf an incompetent person is employed or required to do a job that they are not capable of doing, then there will be a breach of the employer's duty (Black v Fife Coal Ltd [1912] … flights dca to viennaWebMay 27, 2024 · Butler v Fife Coal Co Ltd; HL 1912 - [1912] AC 149 Trim Joint District School Board of Management v Kelly [1914] AC 667 1914 HL Earl Loreburn, Viscount Haldane L-C Health and Safety Viscount Haldane LC said: "the construction of the Act ought to be more liberal as regards the claims of the workman than would be the case if the Act … flights dca to st luciaWebAug 14, 2024 · extending to obvious matters such as providing a safe place of work and safe equipment, this duty can extend to other matters as well. For instance, duty of care can … chen exo love shot